AdvertiseSend a TipContact

The Weekly High Society Digest

The City Politic

Gary Barnett’s $80 Million Week: Air Rights on East 61st, a Dive Bar Site in Yorkville and a Souvenir Shop on Sixth

Extell paid Hartz Mountain $34.9 million for air rights to grow its 74-story tower at 655 Madison Avenue, $27.9 million for a long-planned housing site at 1645 First Avenue and $18 million for a four-story building on Avenue of the Americas. Three deals, three neighborhoods, one developer who keeps buying while others wait.

The glass-and-steel office building at 655 Madison Avenue at the corner of East 60th Street

Most of Manhattan’s developers spent this fall talking about the cost of money. Gary Barnett spent it buying. Property records made public last week show that Extell Development, the firm Barnett founded in 1989, closed three transactions worth about $80.8 million in three different neighborhoods, each one a piece of a larger plan.

Madison and 60th

The largest was a $34.9 million purchase of air rights from Hartz Mountain Industries attached to 34 and 36 East 61st Street, Commercial Observer reported, citing filings made Tuesday, Nov. 10. The development rights are meant for 655 Madison Avenue, at the corner of East 60th Street, where Extell is planning a 74-story mixed-use tower with 154 condominiums above about 233,000 square feet of office and retail space. Chanel has been mentioned as a potential tenant.

Barnett has been assembling the site piece by piece. Extell bought the corner from Williams Equities for $160 million in 2024, paid $103 million for 33-39 East 60th Street in March 2025 and, in February of this year, paid the Metropolitan Club $39.9 million to transfer 135,146 square feet of air rights from its clubhouse at 1 East 60th Street. Add last week’s purchase and the land and air-rights bill for the project is now about $338 million, before a shovel goes in the ground.

The white marble Metropolitan Club building on Fifth Avenue at East 60th Street
The Metropolitan Club at 1 East 60th Street, which sold Extell 135,146 square feet of air rights in February. Photo by Jim.henderson via Wikimedia Commons, CC0.

That is the Extell method, and it has been for decades: buy the corner, then buy the sky over the neighbors, and build taller than anyone thought the block allowed. It is how Barnett built One57 and Central Park Tower on Billionaires’ Row, and it is why his projects draw both buyers and opponents. Neighbors and preservationists have long argued that transferred air rights let developers build towers the zoning map never envisioned. Barnett’s answer has been that the rights are legal property, bought and paid for, and that the city’s most valuable addresses are exactly where demand for new apartments is strongest.

First Avenue

The second deal is more modest and, for housing, more consequential. On Monday, Nov. 9, a deed filing showed Extell paying $27.9 million to Jay and Stuart Podolsky of Amsterdam Hospitality Group for 1645 First Avenue, a vacant Yorkville site between East 85th and 86th streets that once housed a dive bar, PropertyWireDaily reported, summarizing Commercial Observer. Extell filed plans there in 2021 for a 542-unit housing project, according to PincusCo. Extell has not said what it will build now.

A 542-unit building on the Upper East Side would be a substantial addition in a neighborhood that has added relatively little rental housing in recent years. Whether the plan survives in that form depends on the economics of rental construction in a city where the rent-stabilized stock is under strain and new tax incentives come with affordability conditions. A developer that pays nearly $28 million for a site it has been planning for five years is presumably confident that the numbers can work.

Sixth Avenue

The third deal, also recorded Monday, Nov. 9, was an $18 million purchase of a four-story commercial building at 1190 Avenue of the Americas, now leased to a souvenir shop, from Lighthouse Properties and Solil Management. Extell is already building a 29-story office and retail building on the same block, anchored by a full-size Ikea store. Weeks earlier it paid $24 million for 87,000 square feet of air rights from the Church of St. Mary the Virgin at 145 West 46th Street, on the same block.

The Gothic stone facade of the Church of St. Mary the Virgin on West 46th Street
The Church of St. Mary the Virgin near Times Square, which sold Extell 87,000 square feet of air rights this fall. Photo by Americasroof at English Wikipedia via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The pattern there is the same as on Madison: a small building and a church’s unused development rights, absorbed into a larger plan for the block. Churches with landmarked buildings and limited endowments have become reliable sellers of air rights in Midtown, and St. Mary the Virgin is the latest. For the congregation, the sale converts something it could never use into money it can. For the block, it means more height somewhere nearby.

The skeptic’s view

There is a cautious reading of the spree. Extell carries a great deal of land and development risk at once, across the Upper East Side, Times Square and Midtown, and a luxury condominium tower on Madison Avenue will come to market years from now into a city that has added a surcharge on expensive second homes and is debating taxes on the wealthy. Supertall condominiums take years to sell out, and air rights do not build themselves.

The bull case is the one Extell has made for years: Manhattan’s supply of new condominiums is thin, the best corners are rarely for sale, and a developer who assembles them while capital is expensive will own them when it is cheap.

What to watch

The filings to watch are a new-building application at 1645 First Avenue, which will show whether the 542-unit plan survives, and the next steps for 655 Madison, including construction financing and a condominium offering plan. On Sixth Avenue, the question is whether the souvenir shop is a tenant for a while or a building on its way down. If the past is a guide, Barnett is not finished buying on any of these blocks.

Featured image: 655 Madison Avenue at East 60th Street, the corner where Extell plans a 74-story tower (2023 photo). Photo by Jonathan Schilling via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

More from The City Politic

Leave a Reply

Comments (

0

)