At about 4 p.m. on Wednesday, Nov. 11, a three-story building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue came down. It was a mixed-use building from the 1930s, with apartments upstairs and a store at street level, and it was fully occupied. Next door, crews were digging the foundation for a new building. Much of the old one fell into that hole.
By Thursday afternoon the toll was eight dead and 18 injured. Six adults and two children were killed, two of them construction workers, Mayor Zohran Mamdani said at a briefing, CBS New York reported. Six people died at the scene and two in the hospital. Four of the injured are firefighters. One person remained in critical condition.
The victims
The dead included two children who lived in the building, Nicole Daniela Salvada Rodriguez, 9, and Kevin Santiago Reyes Gonzalez, 10, and three adult residents, Juan Daniel Salvada Guzman, 31, Barry Mamadou, 23, and Ndiaye Mamadou, 31, according to a senior police official cited by CBS and the BBC. Three victims lived elsewhere in the city: Gabriel Siguencia, 22, of the Bronx; Edgar Sapon, 26, of Hell’s Kitchen; and Jose Luis Caguana Cosquillo, 26, of Bushwick. Ecuador’s consul general visited the site and confirmed that two of the dead were Ecuadorian nationals.
“These were our friends and our neighbors, parents and children, young families building their lives in our city, and immigrants from Mexico, Colombia, Ecuador, Trinidad and beyond,” Mamdani said.

The rescue
Firefighters arrived within a minute of the first 911 call, the mayor said, and more than 250 fire and EMS personnel worked through the night. The New Rochelle Fire Department volunteered help overnight. Fire Commissioner Lillian Bonsignore called the response “incredibly heroic.” Rescue operations ended about 24 hours after the collapse, once fire officials concluded no one else was trapped, and the site was turned over to the Department of Buildings and the police.
Some of the first rescuers were the people working the excavation. “Construction workers who had only barely survived themselves turned back and dug victims out of the rubble,” Mamdani said. “People are alive today because of their heroism yesterday.” One woman pulled from the debris on video was six months pregnant, her husband told CBS. “She is alive,” he said. “I’m very happy.”
The construction site
The investigation will turn on what was happening next door, and the record so far is incomplete. Plans approved for the adjacent site call for a building with 64 apartments and a grocery store on the ground floor. Developers had active permits for excavation and foundation work, investigators said.
The Buildings Department told Construction Dive that it issued a stop-work order and a violation on the site on March 20, during demolition, after inspectors found inadequate overhead protection for neighboring properties. When inspectors returned on April 23, they found demolition had resumed, and they issued another violation. The order was lifted on May 8 after the conditions were corrected. Permits reviewed by Construction Dive list Robert Fischman of W6 Facility X as the owner and Cheng-Yi Lin Architecture as the architect of record. No one has been charged with wrongdoing, and the cause of the collapse has not been determined.
Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani said there were no reported code violations on the building that fell. After the collapse, the department issued a new stop-work order on the construction site citing “unsafe construction operations.” The city also said five companies are associated with the site, and that those companies are tied to about 100 other jobsites. “The Department of Buildings is commencing sweeps of those sites,” the mayor said, PIX11 reported. “If there is anyone or any entity operating in this city that bears responsibility for what happened, we will hold them fully accountable,” Tigani said.

Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez said his office is working with the Buildings Department and the police “to determine whether any criminal conduct contributed to this tragedy.”
The inquiry widened at the end of the week. On Friday, Nov. 13, Tigani said the city had hired an engineering firm to produce an independent report on the collapse and was examining 160 building sites connected to the companies behind the project, The New York Times reported. At a separate news conference with victims’ families, Attorney General Letitia James and Council Speaker Julie Menin, Council Member Farah Louis, who represents the area, said records showed “a building with nearly 100 open violations sitting next to an excavation site, cited for violating a stop work order.” Menin promised to strengthen the city’s building rules and noted that the Buildings Department has a vacancy rate above 8 percent.
On Saturday, Nov. 14, Public Advocate Jumaane Williams said the collapsed building’s registered head officer with the city housing agency, Olufemi Falade, had appeared on the public advocate’s Worst Landlord Watchlist six times in the past decade, most recently in 2024, FOX 5 reported. The list ranks landlords by open housing-code violations, which are tracked by the Department of Housing Preservation and Development rather than the Buildings Department. “While we don’t yet know exactly what caused the collapse,” Williams said, “it is essential that any negligence which may have contributed be identified.” Falade has not been accused of causing the collapse.
What engineers are saying, and not saying
It is too early for anyone to say why the building fell, and the engineers who have spoken publicly have been careful. Joe DiPompeo, president of the civil engineering firm Structural Workshop, told Construction Dive that digging next to an old building is ordinary in New York. “There’s nothing unusual about digging a hole next to a 100-year old brownstone townhouse in the city,” he said, and he cautioned against assuming the excavation crew caused the failure. But he also explained why shoring matters: “If the supportive excavation, the soil bracing were to fail or not do what it was supposed to do, the building that fell into the hole would fall into the hole exactly the way it did.”
Timothy Hegarty, a construction lawyer at Zetlin & De Chiara, noted that new construction routinely happens “inches from century-old buildings, so the margin of error can be extraordinarily small,” and that collapses like this one are rare precisely because of the diligence the code requires.
The neighborhood
For now, the block is a recovery zone. Vacate orders cover 1323, 1325 and 1327 Flatbush Avenue, and Flatbush is closed between Clarendon Road and Bedford Avenue. The B41, B49, B103, B8 and BM2 buses are on detours. “I live literally right behind the building,” a neighbor, Emmanuella Carilus, told The New York Times. “It sounded like a big boom and you just heard a bunch of screaming.”
What to watch
Three questions will shape what comes next. First, what the Buildings Department finds about the excavation and its support of the neighboring foundation, and whether the earlier stop-work history bears on it. Second, what the sweeps of the 160 related sites turn up. Third, whether the district attorney finds grounds for charges. Displaced residents of the neighboring buildings also face the practical question of when, or whether, they can go home.
Featured image: The Crown Heights firehouse of FDNY Rescue Company 2, one of the department’s heavy-rescue companies in Brooklyn (file photo). Photo by DanTD via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.






Leave a Reply