AdvertiseSend a TipContact

The Weekly High Society Digest

The City Politic

Frank Lloyd Wright’s Only New York House Gets an Addition. The Urns Should Stay in Buffalo.

The Landmarks Preservation Commission has approved, with modifications, an addition to the Crimson Beech, Wright’s prefab Usonian house on Staten Island. The restoration around it is real stewardship. The borrowed ornament was the wrong idea.

Partial front view of the Crimson Beech, a long low Frank Lloyd Wright house with cream panels and red brick

Criticism and opinion.

There is exactly one house in New York City designed by Frank Lloyd Wright, and it came in a kit. In 1959 William and Catherine Cass ordered a Prefab No. 1 from Marshall Erdman, Wright’s builder in Madison, Wis., had the components shipped east and assembled them on a sloping lot at 48 Manor Court, on Lighthouse Hill in Staten Island. The parts cost $20,000 and the assembly $35,000. The house became known as the Crimson Beech, for a tree on the property. The city made it a landmark in 1990, and it remains a private home.

On Tuesday, Nov. 10, the Landmarks Preservation Commission voted 9 to 0 to approve, with modifications, an application by its owners to build an addition, repave the driveway and legalize work done at the rear of the house without the commission’s permits, according to the commission’s agenda. The agenda does not say what the modifications are; that will be in the commission’s written decision. But the debate that led to them is on the record, and it is worth having, because it is a debate about what kind of architect Wright was.

What Wright was doing here

The Prefab No. 1 is not Fallingwater. Wright designed it in 1956 to answer the question of the moderately priced American house, using factory-made components instead of expensive site-built construction. The Cass house is a long, low L with wide hip roofs, red brick and cream-colored panels striped with redwood battens, one story in front and two at the back where the land falls away. Inside, the walls are Philippine mahogany. It is a Usonian house, Wright’s term for his modest, democratic, horizontal homes, and its virtue is restraint.

It has been altered before, and well. In 1970 the pool, its brick walls and its steps were added by Morton H. Delson, whom Wright had chosen as his East Coast representative. Those changes, as the landmark designation report notes, respected the original character.

A house on a wooded street on Lighthouse Hill, Staten Island
A house on Meisner Avenue on Lighthouse Hill, the Staten Island neighborhood of the Crimson Beech. Photo by Jim.henderson via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

What the owners proposed

The owners’ presentation to the commission at its first hearing on Aug. 4, prepared by Urban Cartographics, describes a house that needed help. They have repaired the metal roofs with new membranes and insulation, installed curbing and drains to stop water getting in, cleared dead and overgrown landscaping so the house can be seen from the street, and stabilized a pool that, in the presentation’s words, had been lifted by hydrostatic pressure. They proposed replacing an asphalt driveway with pavers closer to the red brick the original plans called for, and planting a new crimson beech.

All of that is stewardship, and the owners deserve credit for it. Landmark owners are not obliged to love their houses. These ones evidently do.

The addition is mostly clever. It is a cellar extension tucked into the slope, under a green roof, so that from Manor Court it nearly disappears. The Victorian Society New York, which testified at the August hearing, supported that part, noting that it would be minimally visible from the street and that its pool-side face would match the existing lower level.

The trouble was at the western end. There the extension culminated in a pavilion with a dramatic triangular roof, visible from the street. And along the roofline the design put piers topped with decorative urns, a detail the presentation credits, under the heading “Frank Lloyd Wright Design Inspiration,” to the Darwin D. Martin House in Buffalo. New exterior doors took their cue from Taliesin, Wright’s Wisconsin home.

The Darwin D. Martin House in Buffalo, a long Prairie-style brick house
The Darwin D. Martin House in Buffalo, designed by Wright in the Prairie period and the source of the urn detail proposed for the Staten Island addition. Photo by Dave Pape via Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Why the urns are wrong

The Martin House is one of the masterpieces of American architecture, and its urns belong there. Wright designed it in 1903 to 1905 for a rich Buffalo executive, at the height of the Prairie period, as a custom estate with every detail drawn for one family. The Crimson Beech is the opposite proposition: a house from the end of Wright’s life, designed to be built from parts, for families of moderate means. Quoting the Martin House on a Usonian prefab is not homage. It is like hanging a Tiffany chandelier in a Levittown kitchen because both are American.

The Victorian Society said as much, in more measured language. It called the triangular-roofed pavilion out of keeping with “the low horizontal character and simple detailing typical of Wright’s Usonian houses,” and asked the commission to deny the urns as “alien to the character of a Usonian House.” It quoted the designation report’s own description of the Prefab No. 1 as employing “Wright’s characteristic Usonian vocabulary with its low, horizontal emphasis.”

That is the right test. The question for an addition to a Wright house is not whether each piece can be traced to something Wright once drew. Almost anything can. The question is whether it belongs to this house. A borrowed ornament from a different decade, a different client and a different idea of what a home is fails that test, however good the source.

The permit problem

There is one more thing in the application that deserves a sentence. Part of what the commission approved was the legalization of alterations to the driveway and of new window and door infill at the rear facade, done without its permission. That is common, and the commission handles it routinely. It is still worth saying plainly that the order matters. The owners of the city’s only Wright house should not have to be told that the commission comes first, and the next owner of a lesser landmark will be watching what happens when it does not.

The verdict

Approve the restoration, which the commission has done. Build the addition into the hill, where it does no harm. If the commission’s modifications took the urns off the roofline and brought the pavilion down to the horizontal, it got this exactly right. If they did not, the owners still have time to do it themselves. Wright left New York one house. It should look like the one he designed, not like a sampler of the ones he didn’t.

Featured image: The Crimson Beech, Frank Lloyd Wright’s prefab Usonian house at 48 Manor Court on Staten Island (cropped). Photo by how_long_it_takes (Bill) via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.

More from The City Politic

Leave a Reply

Comments (

0

)