The week in the New York delegation came down to 29 minutes on Tuesday night, Nov. 10. That is how long the House held open a vote, scheduled for 15, on a Republican motion to send Rep. Thomas Massie’s articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Judiciary Committee, where they will expire with the 119th Congress on Jan. 3. The motion passed 211 to 204, ABC News reported.
Eleven Democrats did not vote. ABC’s count shows that if all of them had been there, the motion would have failed, 215 to 211, and the impeachment resolution would have moved forward. One of the eleven was a New Yorker: Rep. Laura Gillen of Long Island’s 4th District.
Gillen’s account
Gillen said she was trying to get there. “Like Rep. Stansbury, I was stuck behind the same police escort blocking the Capitol when Republicans closed the vote,” she wrote on social media, referring to Rep. Melanie Stansbury of New Mexico. “I would have voted no and believe strongly that Pete Hegseth should be impeached.”
Several of the absent members told similar stories about a traffic incident and a bus under police escort near the Capitol. Gillen was one of six who reached the chamber in time for the next vote. Even with those six, ABC calculated, the motion would still have passed, 211 to 210. The other absences included former Speaker Nancy Pelosi, who was at a Veterans Day event in San Francisco, and Rep. Lou Correa of California, who had announced a medical procedure in advance. Members who miss a vote can record how they would have voted in the Congressional Record, but those statements do not change the tally.

What the articles said
Massie, a Kentucky Republican who is leaving Congress and has often broken with President Trump, was the only Republican to side with impeachment. His eight articles accuse Hegseth of starting and continuing the war in Iran without a declaration of war or specific congressional authorization, of ignoring a June directive from Congress to end hostilities, and of exceeding the time limits of the War Powers Resolution, among other charges, CBS News reported.
New York’s Republicans voted with their party to refer the articles. Their case, and the White House’s, is that the war is a policy dispute between Congress and the president, and that impeachment is the wrong tool for settling it. The War Powers Resolution has been contested by presidents of both parties for half a century, and no Cabinet officer has ever been impeached over the conduct of a military campaign. To many Republicans, using the gravest remedy in the Constitution in the last weeks of a lame-duck House, on articles written by a departing member, looked like a political exercise. Trump called Hegseth a “great American patriot” after the vote and attacked Massie for breaking ranks, Scripps News reported.
Ocasio-Cortez and the time clock
Democrats spent the rest of the week explaining. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of the Bronx and Queens allowed that some colleagues might have had legitimate reasons, but she did not hide her frustration. “At the end of the day, we’re here to do a job and the same way I had to clock in when I worked at a restaurant, we got to clock in and do our work here,” she said.

Questions about why some members were away from the Capitol before the vote have not gone away. Some of the absent Democrats were returning from an event held by the super PAC Elect Democratic Women, Democracy Now! reported, citing reporting by The Lever on the group’s spending. The members who have explained themselves have pointed to the traffic, and the House had announced the 5:30 p.m. vote series at least 18 hours in advance, ABC noted.
Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries of Brooklyn signaled that the party was not finished. Democrats take control of the House in January, and some of the members who missed Tuesday’s vote have said they expect to vote to impeach Hegseth then. Rep. Brittany Pettersen of Colorado said as much.
The rest of the week
The vote landed in the middle of Jeffries’ own campaign for speaker, which faces an internal caucus vote on Wednesday, Nov. 18 and resistance from a bloc of incoming members, including two New Yorkers, Representatives-elect Darializa Avila Chevalier and Claire Valdez. The episode gave his critics on the left another argument about discipline in the caucus and gave his defenders an argument about why a large, functioning majority matters: a two-vote margin leaves no room for a stuck bus.
For Gillen, who took her Nassau County seat from a Republican in 2024 and beat Republican Jeanine Driscoll on Nov. 3 to keep it, according to the Long Island Press, the politics cut both ways. Her stated position, that Hegseth should be impeached, is now on the record. So is her absence.
What to watch
In January, the question becomes whether a Democratic House brings new articles against Hegseth, on what grounds, and whether any Republicans besides Massie, who will be gone, join them. In the meantime, the week offered a smaller lesson that every member of the delegation already knew: in a narrowly divided House, the vote is held open only so long.
Featured image: Rep. Laura Gillen of Long Island, one of 11 Democrats who missed the Hegseth vote (official portrait, 119th Congress). Photo by Ike Hayman, House Creative Services via Wikimedia Commons, public domain.






Leave a Reply